ねほり.com

何もないから何かみつかる

Which holding a wine glass is better, by stem or by bowl?

      2018/03/21

Most all of Japanese understand that holding a wine glass by stem is correct way.

boston-wine-tours

Recently, the website of some companies like ASAHlI BEER and KIRIN BEER argue a bit about holding it.

Holding a wine glass by stem is a tasting way for sommeliers.
In International Protocol, it is the right manner to pick up a glass by the bowl.

asahi

In addition, some Japanese editors also post how to hold a wine glass without any correct reasons.

You should always hold the glass by the bowl, no matter what the shape or size of the glass because most of presidents, princes and actors always do so (See the following picture).

Elizabeth II and George Walker Bush

72b01767e6a451583f743b01567bab88

 
 

I cannot believe this story, so I decided to start to investigate the fact!

 
 

At first, I asked ASAHlI BEER about the source of article.

The feedback of this company is below.

We posted this article based on comments from the association of etiquette, protocol and a wine glass manufacturer.
And, accordig to them, holding a wine glass by bowl is common practice historically.

 
 

Who is the association of etiquette, protocol and wine glass manufacturers?

But, ASAHlI BEER did not provide it to me.

I reluctantly looked for old pictures on web to confirm their beliefs.

 
 

pin

Thomas Pelham-Holles, the Duke of Newcastle demonstrates how the glass is being gripped by the foot, the correct way of holding a glass in the seventeenth and early eighteenth century. Producers of TV period dramas and history documentaries please take note, as actors never get this right.

 
 
 

The correct way of holding a glass is to grip by the foot.

 
 

1efac85a1
W-what did you say!?

 
 

This fact goes diagonally above and beyond my imagination…

 
 

Actually, we can find tons of pictures to corroborate the fact.

Man holding a glass of wine (eighteenth century)

unnamed

A Man Holding A Glass Of Wine
by (after) Christiaen Van Couwenbergh

painting1

A SMILING MAN, HOLDING A GLASS OF WINE AT A TABLE, WITH SALAMI, TURNIPS, CHEESE, BREAD, FIGS, MELON AND A CARAFE IN A COOLING BUCKET(mid-17th Century).

170N09515_8T7SX

 
 

It seems to me that holding a wine glass by bowl is not common practice historically,,,,
If not ASAHlI BEER says the following thing….

 
 

The case of mid-13th Century….

Everyone grasps a bowl, because…
 
 

Monk_tasting_wine_from_a_barrel

 
 

It’s a stemless glass!

 
 

 
 

6bdb268061c188eb8fc308553600adde5d345a7678698050ae587492e70b8b09

Is ASAHlI BEER kidding me?

 
 

Secondarily, I looked for pictures of famous people with a wine glass.

Following people hold a wine glass by bowl.

  1. Barack Obama (44th President of the United States)
  2. George Walker Bush (43th President of the United States)
  3. Ronald Wilson Reagan (40th President of the United States)
  4. Francois Hollande (President of the France)
  5. Nicolas Sarkozy (President of the French)
  6. Elizabeth II (Queen of the United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand)
  7. Giorgio Napolitano (The 11th President of Italy)
  8. Silvio Berlusconi (Italian Prime Minister)
  9. Akihito (Emperor of Japan)
  10. Prince William, Duke of Cambridge (British Royal Family)
  11. Juan Carlos I (Spanish King)
  12. George Clooney (American actor)
  13. Meryl Streep (American actress)
  14. Lady GaGa (American singer)
  15. The Beatles (British rock group)

Barack Obama

holdglass

Francois Hollande

1342_3039

Akihito and Francois Hollande

0130607at57_p

Prince William, Duke of Cambridge

wine

The Beatles
beatles

 

This fact makes me embarrassed…

It seems to me that everyone may beleive it is protocol to pick up a glass by the bowl.

 

How does American feel holding way like a primate?

We can find comments on some websites regarding this question.

Clipboard01

One of the biggest and most common mistakes of holding a wine glass is by the bowl section, as the above photo of Mr. Obama demonstrates.

Wine Tips: How to Hold a Wine Glass The Right Way

 

We need to teach Obama how to properly hold stemware!

Oops… Holding a wine glass the wrong way can be embarrassing.

 
 

Just because you are President, doesn’t mean you know how to hold a wine glass.

 
 

How about the holding method of Hollande?

We can also find comments in French.

comment

Malgre cela, les mauvaises habitudes ont la vie dure, et nombreux sont encore ceux qui hesitent entre tenir leur verre par le pied ou par le bulbe (partie qui contient le vin). La bonne reponse? Par le pied, evidemment.

Comment tenir son verre

 
 

Bad habits die hard!

 
 

And, how about the holding method of actors?

Kerry Washington’s character, Olivia Pope on Scandal (TV series), grasp wineglasses by the bowl.

olivia-pope-wine-glass
 
 

 
 

they are almost always holding the glass by the bowl and not the stem. Most wine lovers do the opposite, which is considered proper etiquette.

Why do actors always hold their wineglasses by the bowl rather than the stem?

Conclusion of this battle

I told ASAHlI BEER above information again.

 

Thank you for your feedback.
We will improve the article of page.

by ASAHlI BEER

 
 
We should hold a wine glass according to time, place and occasion.

 
 

I sometimes hear to grab the stem if it’s a chilled white wine.
But, in international dinner, most of presidents hold a wine glass by bowl without any reference to colors.

obama-image-4-952819061

In International dinner, conversation is more important than drinking and eating.
So, they usually hold a wine glass by bowl to provide stability.

 
 
For example, Francois holds it by stem except for international dinner.
 
 

Clipboard01
 
 

This is because holding way does not have any stricted rules!

[Related article]

Which holding a wine glass is better, by stem or by bowl? 4/4(Japanese)

Which holding a wine glass is better, by stem or by bowl? 3/4(Japanese)

Which holding a wine glass is better, by stem or by bowl? 2/4(Japanese)

Which holding a wine glass is better, by stem or by bowl? 1/4(Japanese)

 - 2016年, 歴史, 英語, 調査結果, 食事

  関連記事

clipboard01
アメリカ人に対するステレオタイプと払拭方法

国際コミュニケーション演習課題のレポートをやってみた。 はじめに 現代は「グロー …

cfc10981f7e6ee34805b42b741fcf3f4
炊飯器と麺棒で家庭で餅つき体験

子供の頃、祖母の家には臼(うす)と杵(きね)があり、正月には餅つきをしていた。 …

ramen1
サンノゼの日本料理1 ラーメン編(俺んち、こてつ、SEA)

食べ物ネタでFacebookや日記を書くようになると、他にネタがないと言うことで …

cariboulight206-bk
自転車のチェーン修理方法

通勤用自転車で帰宅の坂道を登っていたとき、自転車で激しく転びました・・・。 自転 …

img_51a39886ccccba3a063b5ff41666f6e685228
サラリーマンは安泰?誰に仕事を奪われのか?

年収が同期の中でも底辺です・・・ 同期がどれだけ出世しているのか概算しました。 …

2014_08_17_2
milpitas ミルピタスでyelpランキングが高い「Banana Leaf Restaurant」

アメリカの料理といえば「ファストフードのハンバーガー」や「ステーキ」が思い出せれ …

Clipboard01
就職人気企業の移り変わりと理由

2005年に就職して、10年以上が経過しました。 同期には既に統括課長もいるそう …

1
小櫃堰公園の池でモツゴ捕り(千葉県木更津市)

千葉県 小櫃川はシーバス(スズキ)釣りで有名です。 その川の横にあるのが小櫃堰公 …

20151201
中国人のサンクスギビング、インド人のクリスマスパーティ

今年の目標に「日本人以外と交流する」というのがありました。 そして、もはや12月 …

13133679
アメリカに移住(渡米)した親族・先祖の調査方法 4

広島県、山口県、熊本県、福岡県は全国でもっとも海外移住者が多かった県です。 この …